ICL 7059: Analysis Scavenger Hunt

 Activity: Module 4 Lesson Plan Scavenger Hunt

• Using resources available on Canvas as well as your own resources, find an example of a workshop approach lesson plan that aligns with your 8th grade math teaching interests and values.
• Go through the lesson plan analysis checklist, linked here. Links to an external site.. 

Share the link to your analysis and your final analysis summary on the discussion board

7059 LESSON PLAN ANALYSIS
Adapted from the Pinning with Pause checklist, created by

Drs. Jennifer Gallagher, Katy Swalwell and Elizabeth Bellows (Complete article here)

To use this template, click File > Make a Copy, then edit your copy to analyze the lesson plan.
Submit the link to Canvas along with your final analysis.

Name: ________________________

Lesson Title (please link or attach lesson)

What subject(s) does this lesson cover?

According to the lesson description/author, what is the learning objective?

What is your prior knowledge about this topic?

What is the target grade/audience?

Section 1: Attributing a Purpose

Yes Maybe No Notes

a. Does the activity, resource, or idea support the inquiry question,
standards, or learning objectives?

b. Is it appropriately challenging for my students? Does it require
critical thinking?

c. Does it purposefully support students being able to make
decisions about what and how they learn?

d. Do the ends justify the means? In other words, is the learning goal
commensurate with how much time and resources it requires?

Section 2: Reliability Assessment

Yes Maybe No Notes

a. Is the content accurate? Can it be corroborated with other credible
sources?

b. Does the author have expertise in the discipline, in pedagogy, or
in my context?

c. Are the representations of people, communities, and issues
authentic and nuanced?

d. Is the content current with up-to-date information?

Section 3: Judging the Perspective

Yes Maybe No Notes

Special thanks to Dr. Noreen Naseem Rodriguez for formatting this into a google doc!

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-KHiVgr-A7LwFZ14TL3tLg3hZHiP7VRW/view?usp=sharing

a. Does the content reflect my students’ cultures or contexts?

b. Does the content give my students windows into new cultures or
contexts?

c. Does it value students’ funds of knowledge, questions, and
expertise?

d. Am I sure that this activity, resource, or idea will not harm students
– especially those with marginalized identities and/or backgrounds?

Section 4: Considering Students’ Needs

Yes Maybe No Notes

a. Does this lesson provide resources or information about how to
adapt or modify the lesson?

b. Does the lesson include specific academic vocabulary that is
clearly defined or explained for students?

c. Does the lesson provide opportunities for students to engage in
the social processes of learning (e.g. group work, sharing knowledge
with one another, peer review, etc.)

d. Does the lesson provide multiple ways for students to engage with
the content (e.g. listening, verbal response, writing, drawing,
making/experimenting, etc.)

Total

Scrap It! Modify It? Keep It!

0-1 Questions in Each Section
Answered Yes

2-3 Questions in Each Section Answered
Yes

4 Questions in Each Section Answered
Yes

This curriculum resource might be
beyond redemption. Scrap it! Consider
searching on national professional
organizations dedicated to your subject.

Your source met some of the criteria but you
may want to modify or supplement with other
materials to be sure your curriculum counts
in appropriate and meaningful ways.

It seems like you have found a great
resource, activity, or idea to use! Save that
gem!

FINAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY: Complete the prompts below, then submit this final analysis along with
the link to your full checklist to Canvas.

1. Write a one sentence summary of the lesson.

2. Provide a 2-3 sentence summary of your analysis. Did you scrap, modify, or keep based on totals?
Why?

3. Make a quick list: what (if anything) did the author of this lesson plan do well that you would like to try or
that you recommend others consider trying? (If you aren’t sure, go back to the text/media for this week.)

●
●
●

Special thanks to Dr. Noreen Naseem Rodriguez for formatting this into a google doc!